Ulva intestinalis has a moderate environmental impact in the Great Lakes.
Potential:
Ulva intestinalis has caused serious negative impacts in marine and coastal areas outside of the Great Lakes region. In these regions, U. intestinalis may form green tides and biofouling mats that cause cascading effects throughout the food web. However, the harmful bloom development seen in marine environments is rare in inland, freshwater populations (Messyasz and Rybak 2011). Large systems like the Great Lakes may experience more negative effects; U. intestinalis typically forms green tides in the Baltic Sea in eutrophic conditions (Alstroem-Rapaport and Leskinen 2002), where it may be associated with food web alterations. In such conditions, grazing pressure often cannot control massive blooms (Lotze et al. 2000, Lotze and Worm 2002).
Ulva intestinalis mats can deplete the available oxygen in the water and increase the production of hydrogen sulphide in the sediment, which can cause population declines in other fauna and flora (Bäck et al. 2000, Cummins et al. 2004, Vadas and Beal 1987). Mats can also shade out native seagrass beds (Cummins et al. 2004) and negatively impact their corresponding communities, as well disrupt feeding by wading birds (Raffaeli et al. 1998). Furthermore, Romano et al. (2003) observed in England an increase in friction drag with the presence of Ulva intestinalis mats, causing a 10% to 56% reduction in current velocities. There was also a significant reduction is sediment erosion.
Ulva intestinalis has the potential to be a superior macrophyte competitor. Lotze et al. (2000) found that this species can produce a propagule bank capable of surviving winter conditions in the Baltic Sea. Such a seed bank allowed U. intestinalis to begin growing two months earlier than many native species, enabling it to escape herbivory and nutrient competition.
Internationally, Ulva intestinalis has also been associated directly or in part with negative impacts on diversity or specific taxa. In Indian coastal areas, filamentous forms of U. intestinalis have been associated with lower faunal community diversity than areas with more bushy algae (Yogamoorthi 1998). In European coastal waters, epiphytic benthic diatoms prefer growing on monosiphonous forms of U. prolifera to colonizing broad and flattened forms of U. intestinalis (Holt 1980). Furthermore, some marine forms of U. intestinalis are more difficult for grazers to handle and ingest than species with more frond structure (Watson and Norton 1985). Epibionts like Ulva can also exert increased drag on snails living in high flow conditions, causing them to invest more energy in foot muscles and less in growth (Wahl 1996). In the Gulf of Maine, blooms of novel floating rope forms have colonized the substrate, causing anoxia with the potential to exert negative impacts on bivalve species (Vadas and Beal 1987). Finally, in conditions of nitrogen scarcity in estuaries and lagoons on the coast of southern California, U. intestinalis can out-compete Ulva expansa (Fong et al. 1996).
There is little or no evidence to support that Ulva intestinalis has significant socio-economic impacts in the Great Lakes.
Potential:
Ulva intestinalis is one of the species that contributes to the 109 kg of seaweed removed every year from recreational beaches in France (Blomster et al. 2002).
Mats of U. intestinalis in England also caused an order of magnitude decrease in abundance of the economically important bivalve Cerastoderma edule (Romano et al. 2003).
There is little or no evidence to support that Ulva intestinalis has significant beneficial effects in the Great Lakes.