Salmo salar has a high environmental impact in the Great Lakes outside of its native range. Realized:
Salmonids are known to serve as hosts for a wide range of non-native diseases, such as furunculosis, viral hemorrhagic septicemia (VHS), and whirling disease, as well as parasites, including Philonema oncorhynchi and Ergasilus nerkae (Crawford 2001). Atlantic Salmon with signs of furunculosis have even been released into the St. Marys River intentionally (Behmer et al. 1993). Of all Great Lakes species, native salmonines such as Lake Trout and Brook Trout are most susceptible to introduced diseases (Crawford 2001). As stocking artificially increases the disease and parasite reservoir to which native fish species are exposed, fisheries managers on Lake Ontario and Lake Huron have expressed concern that they may face a repeat of the Lake Michigan bacterial kidney disease (BKD) outbreak if salmon stocking programs exceed their carrying capacity (Rand and Stewart 1998).
Competition has been investigated in a limited number of studies between native and introduced salmonines (Crawford 2001). In Great Lakes tributaries, the larger and more aggressive introduced Atlantic Salmon appears to outcompete smaller native species for limited food, cover, and stream position (Crawford 2001). In open lake experiments, high overlap between Atlantic Salmon and Lake Trout diets has been observed (Negus 1995). Furthermore, a review of 17 published experiments on interspecific competition between juvenile Atlantic Salmon and Great Lakes native fishes found that very few of those studies were designed in a way to show significant effects of interspecific competition (Fausch 1998). This has likely led to a profound underestimation of Atlantic Salmon’s effects on native fish species (Peters 1991).
However, more recent studies have shown limited competitive advantage and dietary/habitat overlap between Atlantic Salmon and other salmonids. In an artificial stream experiment, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, Chinook Salmon, and Coho Salmon were all superior competitors to Atlantic Salmon, suggesting that Atlantic Salmon may have little impact on the productivity of those species (Houde et al. 2017). In Lake Ontario tributaries, there was low diet similarity between Chinook Salmon and Atlantic Salmon, suggesting minimal competition (Johnson et al. 2017). In streams in the Lake Ontario watershed, Atlantic Salmon, Rainbow Trout, Chinook Salmon, and Coho Salmon all inhabited distinct habitat types and thus sympatry between the species is likely (Johnson and McKenna 2017). Further, reintroductions of Atlantic Salmon into Lake Ontario tributaries are so far not having any competitive impacts on other fishes (Larocque et al. 2021). In a small fishery in Lake Huron, stable isotope analysis suggested that despite Atlantic Salmon having a considerable trophic niche overlap with Chinook Salmon and Coho Salmon, it had a lower consumptive demand of prey fishes relative to the other salmon. However, long term impacts of stocking Atlantic Salmon in Lake Huron are unknown (Gerig et al. 2019).
Predation of native forage species by introduced salmonines is a concern, as the stocked Atlantic Salmon are generalist vertebrate predators and have the ability to feed on a wide variety of prey. This is a heightened concern in Great Lakes tributaries where juvenile and stream resident Atlantic Salmon forage on a common supply of native species, including invertebrates and fish (Crawford 2001). In open lakes, salmon feed on introduced Alewife and Rainbow Smelt, as well as native Sculpin, Bloater, and Yellow Perch. As Alewife populations decline, it is predicted that salmonine species will shift their diets to include a greater proportion of native species. This could expose those forage species to excessive mortality, especially if salmon stockings exceed the carrying capacity (Crawford 2001). It is also important to note that Atlantic Salmon health and mortality is significantly impacted by thiamine deficiencies caused by consuming Alewife (Ladago et al. 2020). Stocking of Atlantic Salmon in the Great Lakes may also have unintended impacts on other important recreation fishes. A significant portion of reintroduced Atlantic Salmon diets in Lake Ontario tributaries contained Rainbow Trout eggs, but long term impacts are uncertain (Johnson et al. 2016).
Genetic alteration of Great Lakes native species by introduced salmonines has been observed directly, through hybridization and introgression, and indirectly, associated with declines in population and abundance of natives as a result of intensive stocking (Crawford 2001), but it is unknown if Atlantic Salmon has been involved. Hybridization and introgression between Atlantic Salmon and another Great Lakes introduced species, the Brown Trout (Salmo trutta), is common both in Europe (Payne et al. 1972; Youngson et al. 1992, 1993; Jordan and Verspoor 1993; Hartley 1996; Jansson and Ost 1997) and in North America (Verspoor and Hammar 1991; McGowan and Davidson 1992). In contrast, there are no reported cases of hybridization between the Atlantic and Pacific salmonid species in the wild in North America, South America, New Zealand, or Europe (Waknitz et al. 2002). Hybridization in North American rivers has been observed at significantly higher frequencies than those observed in Europe (Verspoor 1988). Thus, wild hybridization between sympatric salmonines may be much more common and ecologically significant than previously thought (Sorensen et al. 1995).
Due to the multiple distinct genetic strains of Atlantic Salmon that are stocked in a singular location, outbreeding depression is a possible impact. The interbreeding of these different genetic populations with wild salmon can ultimately lead to reduced fitness via the loss of local adaptations and can negatively impact populations (Houde et al. 2015). However, under certain conditions, fitness can instead be increased if a population possesses a beneficial genetic adaptation (Houde et al. 2011). In Norway, introgression of wild and farmed Atlantic Salmon is expected to reduce population productivity and diminish resilience to environmental stressors (Glover et al. 2017).
Introduced salmonines have also been seen to have effects on water chemistry and the physical environment. A massive influx of organic matter and nutrients, as well as contaminants, is transported upstream from lakes to tributaries during spawning migrations (Richey et al. 1975; Bilby et al. 1996, 1998; Cedarholm et al. 1999; Crawford 2001). However, most Atlantic Salmon spawning migrations occur in Lake Ontario tributaries within their historical native range, so their net impact on water chemistry is limited. Spawning salmon have been seen to dig up the redds (nests) of native fish and to otherwise superimpose their redds on native fish habitat. Such physical alterations impart community level effects on the abundance and distribution of native fish in affected tributaries (Fukushima et al. 1998; Crawford 2001). In addition, the native Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) typically buries its eggs in redds that are shallower than Atlantic salmon redds (DeVries 1997). Subsequent Atlantic Salmon spawning can lead to the displacement of Brook Trout embryos (Fukushima et al. 1998).
Potential:
Wild and farmed Atlantic Salmon in other parts of the United States and the world are host to a variety of diseases and parasites that could pose a threat to native and introduced salmonids in the Great Lakes. This species is susceptible to the Piscine reovirus (PRV), the Infectious haematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) (Morton et al. 2016), and the Salmonid alphavirus (SAV). SAV can infect both Atlantic Salmon and Rainbow Trout, leading to pancreatic disease and sleeping disease that have high mortality rates. SAV is currently only in Europe and trade of salmonids is banned unless tested for the virus (Deperasinska et al. 2018). In British Columbia, Canada, there is a high prevalence of Piscine orthoreovirus (Strain PRV-1) in farmed salmon. Piscine orthoreovirus can pose a risk of developing heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) in wild Atlantic Salmon, Rainbow Trout, and other salmonids (Di Cicco et al. 2018). However, the long term stability of the virus in natural environments is unknown (Poliniski et al. 2020). An initial study in Norway found little evidence that freshwater salmonids contain Piscine orthoreovirus (Garseth and Biering 2018).
In Norway, salmon gill poxvirus (SGPV) in fresh and saltwater causes apoptosis and immune impairment in Atlantic Salmon (Gjessing et al. 2017). A North American variant of SGPV was found in New Brunswick, Canada. However, the impact or significance of its discovery in regard to salmonids in Canada is uncertain (LeBlanc et al. 2019).
Atlantic Salmon are a host to ectoparasite Gyrodactylus salaris, which can infect many salmonid species and has devastated Atlantic Salmon stocks in Norway (Soleng and Bakke 1997; Sanddodden et al. 2018).
There is little or no evidence to support that Salmo salar has significant socio-economic impacts in the Great Lakes outside of its native range.
Potential:
Atlantic Salmon are host to a variety of parasites and diseases that could impact fisheries and recreation, however, no outbreaks or significant impacts have been reported in the Great Lakes.
Salmo salar has a high beneficial effect in the Great Lakes outside of its native range.
The Atlantic Salmon is renowned among anglers and is a highly prized food fish. It is for these reasons that stocking attempts in the upper Great Lakes have been made for more than a century (Crawford 2001). Even with the limited establishment success that has been experienced, MacCrimmon (1977) argues that attempts to establish this species in the Great Lakes will probably never cease.
Atlantic Salmon introductions into the St. Marys River from West Grand Lake, Maine continue to support local sport fisheries and attract anglers from all over the country (Behmer et al. 1993). Though once native to Lake Ontario, the Lake Ontario Atlantic Salmon Restoration Program is an ongoing project with the aim of re-establishing self-reproducing Atlantic Salmon populations in Lake Ontario tributaries. As part of this project, over 2.7 million individuals have been stocked as of early 2011 (OFAH 2011). Even though Atlantic salmon are a relatively minor component of the Lake Ontario fishery, they contribute to the diversity of trophy salmon and trout available to anglers. (NYSDEC 2020).
Atlantic Salmon historically have a high commercial value in the Great Lakes region (Kerr 2010). At present, numerous aquaculture facilities support the intensive stocking programs in Lake Huron and Lake Ontario in order to re-establish self-sustaining populations of Atlantic Salmon (USFWS/GLFC 2010). While many of the commercial fisheries in the Great Lakes have reduced or ceased production following the decline in Atlantic Salmon populations, some First Nations fisheries are still active under the Indigenous Food, Social, and Ceremonial (FSC) licensing program in Canada as Atlantic Salmon have significant social, economic, and cultural value (Myrvold et al. 2019).